I have been testing my bots for over 2 months now. They are running in the cloud server. I see too often that orders are not being executed, or that trades are missed.
Both bots should trigger an order with the OnBar method, so there is no room for interpretation. also, analysis is done on the 4h timeframe. I have no issues with backtests. When I start the bot up, the first week I am not having any problems, which means that over time the software is letting me down.
Is anyone else having these issues? This is quite frustrating since other people want to invest in my bots. But currently they are not reliable enough to provide that service.
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
I did a check with backtesting, and the bot definitely misses trades. One position from last week was not taken and closed, and another one at the end of the week was not opened. See the screenshot of the trades that were taken in the backtest, but not with my bot running.
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
I did a check with backtesting, and the bot definitely misses trades. One position from last week was not taken and closed, and another one at the end of the week was not opened. See the screenshot of the trades that were taken in the backtest, but not with my bot running.
Unfortunately I cannot help you with such information. You need to follow my advise in my previous post. Add logs to your cBot to understand what happens in real time execution. Also compare it with execution on a VPS
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
I did a check with backtesting, and the bot definitely misses trades. One position from last week was not taken and closed, and another one at the end of the week was not opened. See the screenshot of the trades that were taken in the backtest, but not with my bot running.
Unfortunately I cannot help you with such information. You need to follow my advise in my previous post. Add logs to your cBot to understand what happens in real time execution. Also compare it with execution on a VPS
Hello. I came across the same problem this morning. I think it is due to incorrect value of the MACD. See attached images.
MACD is the leading indicator to close positions. At 06:00 the MACD flipped negative, meaning that the position should be closed. But the value is not printed as negative, but as a formula: -8.282095762690567E-05. At 10:00 am the MACD is printed as -0,0001373403922979577 and the position is closed.
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
I did a check with backtesting, and the bot definitely misses trades. One position from last week was not taken and closed, and another one at the end of the week was not opened. See the screenshot of the trades that were taken in the backtest, but not with my bot running.
Unfortunately I cannot help you with such information. You need to follow my advise in my previous post. Add logs to your cBot to understand what happens in real time execution. Also compare it with execution on a VPS
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
I did a check with backtesting, and the bot definitely misses trades. One position from last week was not taken and closed, and another one at the end of the week was not opened. See the screenshot of the trades that were taken in the backtest, but not with my bot running.
Unfortunately I cannot help you with such information. You need to follow my advise in my previous post. Add logs to your cBot to understand what happens in real time execution. Also compare it with execution on a VPS
Hello. I came across the same problem this morning. I think it is due to incorrect value of the MACD. See attached images.
MACD is the leading indicator to close positions. At 06:00 the MACD flipped negative, meaning that the position should be closed. But the value is not printed as negative, but as a formula: -8.282095762690567E-05. At 10:00 am the MACD is printed as -0,0001373403922979577 and the position is closed.
Can you look into this?
Thanks,
Vince
Any ideas? Is it possible to stop the formula results but calculate the MACD as a absolute value?
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
I did a check with backtesting, and the bot definitely misses trades. One position from last week was not taken and closed, and another one at the end of the week was not opened. See the screenshot of the trades that were taken in the backtest, but not with my bot running.
Unfortunately I cannot help you with such information. You need to follow my advise in my previous post. Add logs to your cBot to understand what happens in real time execution. Also compare it with execution on a VPS
Hello. I came across the same problem this morning. I think it is due to incorrect value of the MACD. See attached images.
MACD is the leading indicator to close positions. At 06:00 the MACD flipped negative, meaning that the position should be closed. But the value is not printed as negative, but as a formula: -8.282095762690567E-05. At 10:00 am the MACD is printed as -0,0001373403922979577 and the position is closed.
Can you look into this?
Thanks,
Vince
Any ideas? Is it possible to stop the formula results but calculate the MACD as a absolute value?
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
Hi Panagiotis,
Thanks for the advise. I will add in logs and run the bots simultaneously on my own VPS and the cloud server to understand the issues. Once I spot a discrepancy I will let you know.
I did a check with backtesting, and the bot definitely misses trades. One position from last week was not taken and closed, and another one at the end of the week was not opened. See the screenshot of the trades that were taken in the backtest, but not with my bot running.
Unfortunately I cannot help you with such information. You need to follow my advise in my previous post. Add logs to your cBot to understand what happens in real time execution. Also compare it with execution on a VPS
Hello. I came across the same problem this morning. I think it is due to incorrect value of the MACD. See attached images.
MACD is the leading indicator to close positions. At 06:00 the MACD flipped negative, meaning that the position should be closed. But the value is not printed as negative, but as a formula: -8.282095762690567E-05. At 10:00 am the MACD is printed as -0,0001373403922979577 and the position is closed.
Can you look into this?
Thanks,
Vince
Any ideas? Is it possible to stop the formula results but calculate the MACD as a absolute value?
Hi there,
The way the results are printed is just the scientific notation and this is used for convenience when there are too many decimals in the actual value. It does not affect how the values are used in your cBot.
PanagiotisCharalampous
03 Oct 2024, 05:34
Hi there,
We didn't have any similar reports. Did you try debugging your cBot i.e. adding logs and understand what happens after this first week? Did you try comparing by executing using your own VPS? Is there a difference in execution?
Best regards,
Panagiotis
@PanagiotisCharalampous